When a business takes on new investment or brings additional shareholders on board, there are two documents that are discussed. These documents are the investment agreement and the Shareholders’ Agreement, while they’re closely related and often drafted around the same time, they serve very different purposes.
Understanding the distinction between these documents matters, because getting it wrong can leave gaps in how your company is protected during a funding round and beyond.
What Is an Investment Agreement?
An investment agreement is a contract between a company and the investor providing the company with funding. It sets out the specific terms of that particular investment transaction.
This will include:
- The amount being invested and the company’s valuation.
- The type of security being issued, such as ordinary shares, preference shares, or convertible loan notes.
- Conditions precedent that must be satisfied before the money changes hands, such as due diligence or regulatory approval.
- Warranties and representations made by the company about its financial position, contracts, and liabilities.
- Any investor protections, such as veto rights over certain decisions or information rights going forward.
An investment agreement is transaction-specific. It governs the deal itself, rather than how the company is run once the investment has completed.
What Is a Shareholders’ Agreement?
A Shareholders’ Agreement is a private contract between the shareholders of a company that governs the ongoing relationship between them.
Rather than focusing on a single funding round, it sets the rules for how the business will be run day to day, and what happens in various future scenarios.
Common parts included in a shareholders’ agreement are:
- Voting rights and the process for making major decisions.
- The structure and powers of the board of directors.
- How shares can be issued, sold, or transferred.
- Dividend policy and profit distribution.
- Dispute resolution procedures.
- Exit provisions, such as what happens on a sale of the business.
A company can have a Shareholders’ Agreement even if it has never taken on outside investment. It’s simply good practice whenever there’s more than one shareholder involved, helping to prevent misunderstandings and disputes further down the line.
Key Differences Between an Investment Agreement and a Shareholders’ Agreement
Purpose
An investment agreement exists to document and protect a specific funding transaction. A Shareholders’ Agreement exists to govern the ongoing relationship between the people who own the company.
Parties Involved
An investment agreement is typically between the company and the incoming investor(s). A Shareholders’ Agreement is usually signed by all the shareholders, both new and existing, along with the company itself.
When They’re Used
Investment agreements are drafted specifically around a funding round, whether that’s a seed round, Series A, or later-stage investment. Shareholders’ Agreements are often put in place at incorporation, when a new shareholder joins, or alongside an investment round if one doesn’t already exist.
Duration
An investment agreement’s core obligations are usually satisfied once the investment is complete, though certain terms can continue afterwards. A Shareholders’ Agreement is intended to remain in force for the life of the company, or until the shareholders agree to update it.
It’s worth noting that investors are often shareholders too. Where that’s the case, the two documents are frequently negotiated side by side, with the Shareholders’ Agreement amended to reflect the investor’s new rights.
How Do These Agreements Interact with the Articles of Association?
Both an investment agreement and a Shareholders’ Agreement need to be considered alongside your company’s Articles of Association, which are a legal requirement for every UK company under the Companies Act 2006.
The Articles are a public document filed at Companies House and take precedence over a Shareholders’ Agreement on matters governed by the Act. If there’s a conflict between the two, it’s the Articles that generally prevail, even though the Shareholders’ Agreement may still be enforceable as a contract between those who signed it.
For this reason, incoming investors will often require the Articles to be amended as a condition of their investment, usually via a special resolution requiring at least 75% shareholder approval. It’s sensible to review your Articles, Shareholders’ Agreement, and any proposed investment agreement together, rather than in isolation, to avoid inconsistencies that could cause problems later.
Do You Need Both Agreements?
In most cases, yes. If you’re a growing business taking on external investment, the investment agreement protects the specific terms of that deal, while the Shareholders’ Agreement protects the working relationship between everyone who owns a stake in the company going forward.
Relying on one without the other can leave gaps. An investment agreement alone won’t tell you how decisions get made once the money is in the bank, while a Shareholders’ Agreement alone won’t capture the detailed warranties, conditions, and protections an investor will usually want around the transaction itself.
Getting these documents drafted properly, whether you’re a founder raising your first round or a business bringing in a new partner, is an important part of protecting the company’s future. This is closely linked to wider contracts and agreements that keep a growing business on solid legal footing, and can also form part of a broader company formation strategy for businesses just starting out.
Contact Our Corporate & Commercial Solicitors for Expert Advice
Whether you’re preparing for a funding round, bringing in a new business partner, or simply want to put a Shareholders’ Agreement in place for the first time, getting the right legal documents drafted is essential.
At Talbots Law, our Corporate & Commercial Team has extensive experience drafting and negotiating investment agreements, Shareholders’ Agreements, and Articles of Association for businesses of all sizes. We’ll help you understand what each document should contain, make sure they work together, and ensure your interests are properly protected.
Contact us today on 0800 118 1500 or get in touch online to arrange a consultation. Let us help you put the right agreements in place before you need to rely on them.
Ask us a question
Disclaimer
The contents of this blog or any other published by Talbots Law cannot be considered as legal advice. You should take no action without prior consultation with a qualified solicitor or legal professional. The contents of this blog refers to the process in England and Wales.
This blog was written by Mike Linford, Head of our Corporate Law Team.